#### Introduction

Lately I was trying to put together some 2D histograms in R and found that there are many ways to do it, with directions on how to do so scattered across the internet in blogs, forums and of course, Stackoverflow.As such I thought I'd give each a go and also put all of them together here for easy reference while also highlighting their difference.

For those not "in the know" a 2D histogram is an extensions of the regular old histogram, showing the distribution of values in a data set across the range of two quantitative variables. It can be considered a special case of the heat map, where the intensity values are just the count of observations in the data set within a particular area of the 2D space (bucket or bin).

So, quickly, here are 5 ways to make 2D histograms in R, plus one additional figure which is pretty neat.

First and foremost I get the palette looking all pretty using RColorBrewer, and then chuck some normally distributed data into a data frame (because I'm lazy). Also one scatterplot to justify the use of histograms.

# Color housekeeping library(RColorBrewer) rf <- colorRampPalette(rev(brewer.pal(11,'Spectral'))) r <- rf(32) # Create normally distributed data for plotting x <- rnorm(mean=1.5, 5000) y <- rnorm(mean=1.6, 5000) df <- data.frame(x,y) # Plot plot(df, pch=16, col='black', cex=0.5)

#### Option 1: hexbin

The

*hexbin*package slices the space into 2D hexagons and then counts the number of points in each hexagon. The nice thing about*hexbin*is that it provides a legend for you, which adding manually in R is always a pain. The default invocation provides a pretty sparse looking monochrome figure. Adding the colramp parameter with a suitable vector produced from colorRampPalette makes things nicer. The legend placement is a bit strange - I adjusted it after the fact though you just as well do so in the R code.##### OPTION 1: hexbin from package 'hexbin' ####### library(hexbin) # Create hexbin object and plot h <- hexbin(df) plot(h) plot(h, colramp=rf)

Using the

*hexbinplot*function provides greater flexibility, allowing specification of endpoints for the bin counting, and also allowing the provision of a transformation function. Here I did log scaling. Also it appears to handle the legend placement better; no adjustment was required for these figures.

# hexbinplot function allows greater flexibility hexbinplot(y~x, data=df, colramp=rf) # Setting max and mins hexbinplot(y~x, data=df, colramp=rf, mincnt=2, maxcnt=60)

# Scaling of legend - must provide both trans and inv functions hexbinplot(y~x, data=df, colramp=rf, trans=log, inv=exp)

#### Option 2: hist2d

Another simple way to get a quick 2D histogram is to use the

*hist2d*function from the*gplots*package. Again, the default invocation leaves a lot to be desired:##### OPTION 2: hist2d from package 'gplots' ####### library(gplots) # Default call h2 <- hist2d(df)

Setting the colors and adjusting the bin sizing coarser yields a more desirable result. We can also scale so that the intensity is logarithmic as before.

# Coarser binsizing and add colouring h2 <- hist2d(df, nbins=25, col=r) # Scaling with log as before h2 <- hist2d(df, nbins=25, col=r, FUN=function(x) log(length(x)))

#### Option 3: stat_2dbin from ggplot

And of course, where would a good R article be without reference to the ggplot way to do things? Here we can use the

*stat_bin2d*function, either added to a ggplot object or as a type of geometry in the call to qplot.##### OPTION 3: stat_bin2d from package 'ggplot' ####### library(ggplot2) # Default call (as object) p <- ggplot(df, aes(x,y)) h3 <- p + stat_bin2d() h3 # Default call (using qplot) qplot(x,y,data=df, geom='bin2d')

Again, we probably want to adjust the bin sizes to a desired number, and also ensure that ggplot uses our colours that we created before. The latter is done by adding the

*scale_fill_gradientn*function with our colour vector as the colours argument. Log scaling is also easy to add using the trans parameter.# Add colouring and change bins h3 <- p + stat_bin2d(bins=25) + scale_fill_gradientn(colours=r) h3 # Log scaling h3 <- p + stat_bin2d(bins=25) + scale_fill_gradientn(colours=r, trans="log") h3

#### Option 4: kde2d

Option #4 is to do kernel density estimation using

*kde2d*from the MASS library. Here we are actually starting to stray from discrete bucketing of histograms to true density estimation, as this function does interpolation.
The default invocation uses n = 25 which is actually what we've been going with in this case. You can then plot the output using

*image().**Setting n higher does interpolation and we are into the realm of kernel density estimation, as you can set your "bin size" lower than how your data actually appear. Hadley Wickham notes that in R there are over 20 packages [PDF] with which to do density estimation so we'll keep that to a separate discussion.*

##### OPTION 4: kde2d from package 'MASS' ####### # Not a true heatmap as interpolated (kernel density estimation) library(MASS) # Default call k <- kde2d(df$x, df$y) image(k, col=r) # Adjust binning (interpolate - can be computationally intensive for large datasets) k <- kde2d(df$x, df$y, n=200) image(k, col=r)

#### Option 5: The Hard Way

Lastly, an intrepid R user was nice enough to show on Stackoverflow how do it "the hard way" using base packages.

##### OPTION 5: The Hard Way (DIY) ####### # http://stackoverflow.com/questions/18089752/r-generate-2d-histogram-from-raw-data nbins <- 25 x.bin <- seq(floor(min(df[,1])), ceiling(max(df[,1])), length=nbins) y.bin <- seq(floor(min(df[,2])), ceiling(max(df[,2])), length=nbins) freq <- as.data.frame(table(findInterval(df[,1], x.bin),findInterval(df[,2], y.bin))) freq[,1] <- as.numeric(freq[,1]) freq[,2] <- as.numeric(freq[,2]) freq2D <- diag(nbins)*0 freq2D[cbind(freq[,1], freq[,2])] <- freq[,3] # Normal image(x.bin, y.bin, freq2D, col=r) # Log image(x.bin, y.bin, log(freq2D), col=r)

Not the way I would do it, given all the other options available, however if you want things "just so" maybe it's for you.

#### Bonus Figure

Lastly I thought I would include this one very cool figure from Computational Actuarial Science with R which is not often seen, which includes both a 2D histogram with regular 1D histograms bordering it showing the density across each dimension.

##### Addendum: 2D Histogram + 1D on sides (from Computational ActSci w R) ####### #http://books.google.ca/books?id=YWcLBAAAQBAJ&pg=PA60&lpg=PA60&dq=kde2d+log&source=bl&ots=7AB-RAoMqY&sig=gFaHSoQCoGMXrR9BTaLOdCs198U&hl=en&sa=X&ei=8mQDVPqtMsi4ggSRnILQDw&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=kde2d%20log&f=false h1 <- hist(df$x, breaks=25, plot=F) h2 <- hist(df$y, breaks=25, plot=F) top <- max(h1$counts, h2$counts) k <- kde2d(df$x, df$y, n=25) # margins oldpar <- par() par(mar=c(3,3,1,1)) layout(matrix(c(2,0,1,3),2,2,byrow=T),c(3,1), c(1,3)) image(k, col=r) #plot the image par(mar=c(0,2,1,0)) barplot(h1$counts, axes=F, ylim=c(0, top), space=0, col='red') par(mar=c(2,0,0.5,1)) barplot(h2$counts, axes=F, xlim=c(0, top), space=0, col='red', horiz=T)

#### Conclusion

So there you have it! 5 ways to create 2D histograms in R, plus some additional code to create a really snappy looking figure which incorporates the regular variety. I leave it to you to write (or find) some good code for creating legends for those functions which do not include them. Hopefully other R users will find this a helpful reference.

#### References

code on github

R generate 2D histogram from raw data (Stackoverflow)

Computational Actuarial Science with R (Google Books)

Wickham, Hadley. Density Estimation in R [PDF]

Thank you for the overview. Of course R ist great and you are not restricted to the 5 options specified in the blog. The contour plot may not be as visually compelling as your option #4, but it is printable in b/w-publications, it is often easier to read the numbers, it is readable for the color blind and it is less arbitrary then color scales tend to be. That is for larger amounts.

ReplyDeleteEven if it is not strictly a histogram I feel, that good old sunflower plot should be mentioned here, as it gives a good overview of the counts of 2D data. Doing the binning yourself you can easily chance it into a histogram.

I am confident, that there is a wealth of other options to display 2D histogram data. Have you looked into pseudo-3D plots like persp and scatter3D / scatterplot3D and the like? Usually "flat" plot will be superior, but not necessary always.

Of course! And you are absolutely correct regarding contour plots, given what we know about perceiving quantity encoded as colour. I was not familiar with sunflower plots, thank you for teaching me something new. There is also the option to use the

Deletestyleparameter in the hexbin function to produced similar output, with style="lattice" or style="nested.centroids"I am generally opposed to 3D visualization (unless it is interactive) as flattening a 3D image into 2D usually results in poor or difficult visualization or both. In my opinion it can be good in certain situations depending on the properties of the data, or used in a supplementary fashion.

And yes, of course, there exists a wealth of options to do data visualization (using R or not); it is up to the one doing analysis to use them appropriately and effectively.

I have to admit, that even though I consider the sunflower plot a usefull plot of it's own right, I have yet to see one in a published paper. People seem to prefer jittered plots even for discrete data. They need even less explanation. The one thing I dislike in them is the random factor.

DeleteThank you very much for linking the "style=lattice" hexbin plot. That is what you thought me today. Looking forward to using that soon.

Cheers,

Bernhard

ggplot2 also has stat_binhex:

ReplyDeletep = ggplot(df, aes(x,y))

p + stat_binhex(bins=25) + scale_fill_gradientn(colours=r)

Ah! Can't believe I missed that! Thank you.

DeleteThe result is quite similar to hexbin.

But they are not histogram. They are scatterplot. Am I wrong?

ReplyDeleteAs I understand it, a scatterplot plots the data itself, a histogramm first bins and counts the data before plotting. Unless the binning is in a lot of shingles and the counting is weighted, then it becomes a density plot. So hexbinning forms histogramms that look very similar to scatterplots.

DeleteCheers,

Bernhard